Ava and Dana shared their first kiss over cream ___. Crossword Clue

 The answer to the crossword clue "Ava and Dana shared their first kiss over cream ___" is PIE. This is a 4-letter word that refers to a dessert made with a pastry crust and a filling of custard, fruit, or cream.

In the context of the clue, Ava and Dana are sharing their first kiss over a slice of cream pie. The pie is a symbol of their love and their commitment to each other. It is also a reminder of the night they met, when they bonded over their shared love of food.

The word "pie" can also be used as a slang term for a woman's buttocks. In this case, the clue is suggesting that Ava and Dana's kiss was passionate and intimate.

I hope this helps!